How To Train A Dog NOT To Do Something
How to Stop Unwanted Dog Behavior Without Harsh Methods
Are you struggling with unwanted dog behaviors like jumping, counter-surfing, or excessive barking? There’s no shortage of dog training advice online—but not all methods are humane, effective, or science-based. At Dog Savvy, we specialize in positive reinforcement dog training (also called reward-based training), which is the fastest, kindest, and most reliable way to teach your dog good behavior.
In this guide, you’ll discover how to stop unwanted behaviors without harsh punishment, using step-by-step strategies that are gentle, consistent, and effective.
Why Dogs Misbehave and How They Learn
Many behaviors dogs enjoy—digging, chewing, barking at noises—are natural instincts, but they aren’t always welcome in our homes. When a dog misbehaves, it usually means they haven’t been taught that the behavior is unwanted or what to do instead.
How Dogs Learn
Dogs primarily learn through associations (what predicts what) and consequences (what happens after a behavior).
Examples:
Your dog gets excited when you pick up the leash because it predicts a walk. They’ve learned that leash = walk.
If your dog jumps on counters and finds food, the behavior is immediately rewarded—even if you scold them afterward. They’ve learned that jumping on counters can lead to food, so they repeat the behavior regardless of scolding.
Why Punishing After the Fact Doesn’t Work
Dogs live in the moment. If a behavior is rewarding—like finding food on a counter—punishing them afterward usually doesn’t outweigh the reward. This makes the behavior likely to continue. Immediate, consistent consequences tied to the behavior are key for effective learning.
Prevention: Stop Unwanted Behavior Before It Happens
Preventing unwanted behaviors before they occur is a key step in successful dog training. By managing your dog’s environment, you stop them from practicing habits you don’t want, making it much easier to teach desirable behaviors. Tools like gates, crates, leashes, or playpens can be invaluable in setting your dog up for success.
Tips for effective prevention:
Control the environment: Use barriers to restrict access to problem areas and crates or playpens to help manage your dog’s environment, to keep your dog away from temptations until they are reliably trained.
Manage triggers: Identify situations or items that spark unwanted behaviors and either remove them or limit your dog’s access until proper training is in place.
Teach alternatives: Don’t just tell your dog what not to do—show them what to do instead. Teach behaviors like sit, down, or go to a designated mat or bed. Provide clear, consistent alternatives that keep your dog engaged and calm.
By proactively preventing misbehavior, you give your dog the opportunity to succeed and make positive reinforcement training far more effective. Prevention isn’t just management—it’s laying the groundwork for long-term success and a happy, well-behaved dog.
👉 RELATED POST: Is your puppy crying in their crate? Discover our proven crate training tips to help them settle calmly and confidently!
Why Harsh Punishment Doesn’t Work
It can be tempting to yell at or physically correct your dog, but harsh punishment often backfires. It can:
Sets unrealistic expectations: You may think your dog “knows better,” but they actually don’t. This can lead to yelling louder or using more force without improving behavior.
Confuses your dog: Without clear feedback, your dog can’t connect punishment to the behavior.
Damages trust: Dogs who fear punishment may stop listening, become anxious around you, or misbehave when unsupervised.
Frustration during training is normal—but verbal or physical punishment only harms your relationship and adds stress for both you and your dog.
What Is Positive Reinforcement Dog Training?
Positive reinforcement is a cornerstone of modern dog training, rooted in animal learning theory. Rather than relying on fear, intimidation, or harsh punishment, it focuses on adding or removing “good things” to communicate consequences and guide your dog toward desired behaviors.
Positive Reinforcement: Introduce something your dog loves—like treats, toys, or praise—to increase the likelihood a behavior will happen again.
Negative Punishment: Remove something your dog wants—such as attention, play, or access to resources—to decrease unwanted behavior.
These methods are clear, consistent, and trust-building, helping your dog understand what’s expected while strengthening your bond. Unlike punishment-based approaches, positive reinforcement encourages cooperation rather than fear.
Step-by-Step Guide to Stop Unwanted Dog Behavior
The key to changing unwanted behaviors is preventing them whenever possible, teaching your dog an appropriate alternative, interrupting the behavior when it occurs, and removing rewards that reinforce the unwanted action.
1. Prevent the Unwanted Behavior
A dog cannot learn not to do something if they are still allowed to practice it. Prevention sets your dog up for success.
Management tools include:
Gates, crates, or playpens: Block access to areas where misbehavior occurs.
Leashes: Maintain control during walks or situations that trigger unwanted behavior.
Remove triggers: Temporarily remove your dog from situations that encourage the behavior.
Environment control: Rearrange or limit access to items that may tempt your dog (for counter-surging, this means keeping food off the counter.
2. Teach a Desired Alternative Behavior
Simply saying “no” is not enough. Dogs need to know what to do instead of the unwanted behavior.
Identify a replacement behavior: For jumping, teach sit, lie down, or go to their bed.
Reward immediately: Give high-value treats, toys, or praise at the exact moment the desired behavior occurs.
Use precise timing: Clickers or verbal markers help dogs connect the action with the reward.
By rewarding the correct behavior consistently, your dog learns that making the right choice is more rewarding than the unwanted behavior.
3. Manage the Moment of Unwanted Behavior
Even with prevention, your dog may attempt undesired behaviors. Here’s how to respond effectively:
Interrupt and redirect: Get your dog’s attention and guide them to the desired alternative behavior.
Withhold reinforcement: Ignore attention-seeking behaviors (like jumping or barking) until your dog is calm.
Short collar holds or leash timeouts: Gently hold your dog’s collar for 10–15 seconds, or use a leash and ask for sit or down to pause the behavior.
4. Use Benign Timeouts Effectively
Timeouts are one of the most effective ways to communicate that a behavior is unacceptable—without fear, intimidation, or punishment.
How to apply timeouts:
Withdraw attention: Turn away, cross your arms, or avoid eye contact.
Step away: Leave the room briefly until your dog is calm.
Gentle collar hold or leash timeout: Pause the behavior and redirect.
Key rules for timeout success:
Be brief: Just long enough to calm your dog.
Be immediate: Apply the timeout as soon as the unwanted behavior occurs.
Be consistent: Use the same consequence every time.
5. Reward Better Choices
Notice when your dog makes a better choice—like entering the kitchen and going to their bed instead of jumping on the counter. Reward calm, polite behaviors immediately with treats, toys, or praise.
Reinforce every small success to build habits gradually.
Example: How to Stop Counter-Surfing
Keep counters clear to prevent reinforcement.
Teach your dog to go to a specific spot in the kitchen, like a bed or an out-of-the-way area.
If you catch your dog in the act, gently grab their collar and remove their paws from the counter.
Give your dog up to three chances to choose a better action, such as sitting, lying down, going to their bed, or leaving the kitchen.
Reward those choices generously using positive reinforcement. If your dog continues attempting to jump, remove them from the kitchen (negative punishment).
Use gates or other management tools to prevent unsupervised access to the kitchen (otherwise, your dog may get sneaky and try to counter-surf when no one is looking).
Tips for Successful Dog Training
Keep sessions short and enjoyable: 5–10 minutes per session keeps your dog engaged and prevents frustration.
Be consistent: Practice regularly in situations where your dog needs guidance, and ensure everyone in your household follows the same rules.
Use high-value rewards: Offer treats, toys, or praise your dog loves to reinforce desired behaviors.
Be patient: It takes 1-2 months to instill a new habit. Positive training takes time, but consistent practice leads to lasting, stress-free results for both you and your dog.
Why Choose Reward-Based Dog Training
Reward-based training:
Builds trust and cooperation
Encourages dogs to listen because they want to, not out of fear
Provides clear communication that dogs can understand
Keeps training fun and stress-free
Ready to Train Your Dog Positively?
👉 Need help stopping unwanted behaviors—without punishment? Book a consultation or online intro session with our certified dog trainer today for expert, personalized guidance tailored to your dog’s unique needs.
About the Author: Certified Dog Trainer Alexandra Bassett
Alexandra Bassett, CPDT-KA, is the founder and head trainer at Dog Savvy, a private dog training company specializing in game-based dog training and behavior solutions for challenges like dog separation anxiety, leash reactivity, excessive barking, and aggression.
Certified by the Council of Professional Dog Trainers (CPDT-KA), Alexandra offers personalized in-home dog training in Salt Lake City as well as convenient online dog training sessions via Zoom for clients worldwide.
👉 Need help managing your dog’s behavior? Book a consultation or online intro session with Alexandra today and get expert, personalized guidance tailored to your dog’s unique needs.